Custom Jewelry Designed Perfectly
Babylon, NY
Custom Designs Made In-House
Repairs Available
Online Shopping Through eBay
Handcrafted Jewelry That Tells Your Unique Story
At East Islip Jewelers, we've been creating stunning custom jewelry for over 50 years. As a local, family-owned business founded in 2009, we've built our reputation on exceptional craftsmanship and personalized service that makes every customer feel special.
Our certified jewelers design and craft each piece right here in our shop, ensuring you'll receive one-of-a-kind jewelry that reflects your personal style. From engagements to anniversaries and other milestones, we'll help you create something truly memorable.
Ready to bring your vision to life? Contact us today and let's start designing your dream piece.

Why Choose Us
Repairs Available
Custom Designs Made In-House
Order Special Out-of-Stock Items
Warranties Available
Products Sold on eBay
Watch Repairs While You Wait

CP #1 Headline
CP #1 Body
CP #1 CTA Lead-in
Not valid with any other offers or promotions. Restrictions apply.
Must mention this coupon at the time of scheduling.

CP #1 Headline
CP #1 Body
CP #1 CTA Lead-in
Not valid with any other offers or promotions. Restrictions apply.
Must mention this coupon at the time of scheduling.

CP #2 Headline
CP #2 Body
CP #2 CTA Lead-in
Not valid with any other offers or promotions. Restrictions apply.
Must mention this coupon at the time of scheduling.
Custom Designed Fine Jewelry
Your jewelry should be as unique as you are. Our in-house team designs and creates custom pieces from concept to completion, crafting one-of-a-kind jewelry with exceptional quality and care.
Custom Engagement Rings
Your engagement ring should be as extraordinary as your love story. Our certified jewelers guide you through selecting the perfect stone, setting, and design to create a ring that reflects your style.
Here's what our satisfied customers are saying...
At East Islip Jewelers, we take pride in providing exceptional custom jewelry, fine jewelry, and jewelry repair services to our customers. We would be grateful if you could share your thoughts about our local, family-owned business with others. Your feedback helps us improve and helps others make informed decisions. Please take a moment to leave a review of East Islip Jewelers and let others know what you think.
FAQs
What types of jewelry services do you currently offer?
We provide a wide variety of fine jewelry options and comprehensive repair services. Our local shop specializes in creating unique items from scratch. People who want beautiful custom engagement rings in Babylon, NY often visit us because we do everything in-house. If you need amazing custom engagement rings in Bay Shore, NY, we are just a short drive away. We also offer repairs while you wait, and laser engraving. We even buy gold from our clients. Whether you want to buy a pre-owned luxury watch or natural diamonds, we have you completely covered. We always guarantee your absolute satisfaction with our personalized service and care.
How does your design process actually work for clients?
When you visit our store, you will meet with our certified jewelers to discuss your specific vision. We listen to your ideas carefully. We then help you choose the best stone and setting to match your personal style perfectly. Many people looking for custom engagement rings in Babylon, NY appreciate this step-by-step guidance. It guarantees you will receive a piece that is truly extraordinary. Those seeking custom engagement rings in Bay Shore, NY also enjoy our extremely thorough approach. We make sure you are completely satisfied before we begin.
Do you sell lab grown diamonds or only natural?
We proudly sell both lab grown diamonds and natural diamonds. Our goal is to provide options that fit your budget and preferences. For couples wanting custom engagement rings in Babylon, NY, we often showcase the brilliant sparkle of our lab-grown selections. Customers shopping for custom engagement rings in Bay Shore, NY frequently ask to compare both types side by side. Our knowledgeable team explains the four Cs so you can make an informed choice. Both types of diamonds look stunning in our handmade settings. We ensure every stone meets standards.
How long will it take to repair my jewelry?
Repair time can vary depending on the type of jewelry and the work required. Simple fixes like chain repairs or clasp adjustments may be completed quickly, sometimes even while you wait. More complex work—such as stone setting, resizing, or intricate restorations—may take longer to ensure the highest quality and care. Our skilled jewelers will assess your piece and provide a clear time estimate before beginning any work, so you know exactly what to expect.
Can you order special items if they are unavailable?
Yes, we certainly can. If you cannot find exactly what you are looking for in our current displays, we can order special out-of-stock items for you. This is extremely helpful for clients searching for rare estate pieces or vintage jewelry. When designing custom engagement rings in Babylon, NY, we sometimes order unique gemstones to complete the look perfectly. Shoppers wanting custom engagement rings in Bay Shore, NY also request specific materials that we gladly source for them. We will go above and beyond to ensure you are completely satisfied.
Do you provide formal appraisals for insurance coverage purposes?
Absolutely. We provide thorough jewelry appraisals to help you properly insure your valuable investments. Many individuals who purchase our handcrafted custom engagement rings in Babylon, NY return shortly after to get a formal appraisal document for their insurance agent. Similarly, those who buy gorgeous custom engagement rings in Bay Shore, NY want to protect their beautiful rings from loss or theft. Our professional team accurately evaluates the current market value of your precious stones and metals. You can feel confident knowing that your paperwork will reflect the true item worth perfectly.
Do you offer watch repair services while I wait?
Yes, we specialize in performing fast watch repairs while you comfortably wait in our showroom. If you have a broken band or need a battery replacement for a pre-owned luxury watch, our experts can handle it quickly. We have all the specialized tools required to open delicate timepieces without causing any scratches or damage. We know that being without your daily watch can be frustrating, so we work efficiently to give it back functioning flawlessly. Stop by anytime to easily restore your timepiece to perfect working condition very quickly today.
Do you purchase old gold from customers directly today?
Yes, we buy gold directly from our local customers. If you have unwanted jewelry lying around your house, bring it into our store for a fair evaluation. We carefully weigh and assess your items right in front of you. This ensures absolute transparency throughout the entire selling process. You can use the cash you receive to purchase something new from our extensive collections, or simply take the money home. We strive to give the highest payout based on current market rates. Our staff makes gold selling simple and rewarding for everyone.
Do you provide warranties on your fine jewelry items?
We absolutely offer warranties on our products because we stand behind our skilled craftsmanship. When you purchase an item from us, we want you to wear it with complete peace of mind. Our warranties cover various types of structural issues and routine maintenance needs. We encourage our customers to visit us regularly for complimentary cleanings and professional prong inspections. Keeping your items properly maintained significantly extends their lifespan and keeps them looking brand new. If you have questions regarding what your warranty includes, our team is available to explain details clearly.
Can I shop your store collections online right now?
Yes, you can easily shop our fantastic inventory online through our dedicated eBay store anytime. This convenient option allows you to browse our latest arrivals from home. We ship items quickly and securely, guaranteeing your new beautiful accessories arrive perfectly intact and ready to wear immediately. Many clients enjoy this service because it saves them a trip. You receive the exact same high-quality pieces delivered directly to your doorstep. If you see something you love online but want to view it first, just visit our local showroom right away today.














